Dew Advisors
SEO claims board

87 SEO claims, tested on a live website

Each claim states what Google's documentation or an open web standard says. Each one was then checked on a real site with a named tool and given a verdict.

This board is a worked example from one engagement. The site isn't named: pages, people and vendors are removed, and large numbers are rounded. Data as of September 7, 2026. The verdicts measure how this one site conforms. They are not evidence that any fix changed rankings.

42
Pass
9
Gap
11
Partial
8
N/A
17
Pending
PassThe site does what the claim says.
GapIt doesn't, and the evidence shows where.
PartialPart of the claim holds, or it holds on only some pages.
N/ANothing on the site to test.
PendingNot decided yet. No evidence, no verdict.
CorrectedThe verdict changed, and the record stays.

What the test found

  • The technical base held up: canonicals, redirects, HTTPS and mobile parity all passed.
  • The problems were in real-user speed, authorship, sourcing and anchor text.
  • Testing improved the list itself. Two claims were added when testing exposed holes in the original 85.
  • Four verdicts were corrected and stay on the record, including one caused by a bug in our own parser.
  • 17 claims are still Pending, including all of cluster 10.

The 10 clusters

Cluster 01 · 12 claims

Crawling, robots.txt, crawl controls and sitemaps

9 Pass · 2 Gap · 1 N/A

robots.txt and sitemap structure are sound. This cluster grew twice during testing, because verification proved the original list of 85 had holes: 1.8.1 (sitemap extension schemas) and 1.8.2 (a sitemap entry must name a live URL). Each new claim was written from the governing documentation, not from the defect that exposed the gap. Both carry the cluster's Gaps. 1.9 moved from Gap to Pass on re-measurement after a fix.

Open cluster 01 →
Cluster 02 · 9 claims

Indexing, canonicalization, HTTP status, redirects and URL structure

7 Pass · 2 Partial

Canonicalization is the strong part: Google's chosen canonical matches the site's declaration on all 25 priority pages, and every redirect is a server-side 301. The two Partials are 2.8 (soft-404 exposure, mostly fixed on re-measurement) and 2.9 (a small set of badly encoded URLs out of everything the sitemaps declare).

Open cluster 02 →
Cluster 03 · 8 claims

JavaScript rendering and content delivery to crawlers

6 Pass · 1 Gap · 1 Partial

The site delivers crawlers a prerendered document and visitors a client-rendered app. 3.1 moved from Gap to Pass after a fix, on the same tool and the same deciding field. Two things are carried openly rather than folded into the Pass: spinners elsewhere are reduced, not gone, and a few URLs outside the priority set still fail, in a variant our own check could not detect at first.

Open cluster 03 →
Cluster 04 · 7 claims

Structured data: policies, supported features and entity types

5 Pass · 1 Gap · 1 Partial

Scope came first: the priority pages don't carry every markup type, so this cluster used a seeded, stratified sample of about 200 URLs across every sitemap class. Re-running the same sample after a fix moved no verdict, and that was the finding: the measurements were stable. Google's own tools, which had been blocked by a user-agent gap, could then confirm them.

Open cluster 04 →
Cluster 05 · 13 claims

Page experience: Core Web Vitals, mobile-first indexing and HTTPS

8 Pass · 2 Gap · 1 Partial · 1 N/A · 1 Pending

The site-side half is clean: HTTPS, redirects, HSTS, mixed content, resource crawlability and mobile/desktop parity all pass across about 180 URLs. The failures are all in field data, and the trend matters more than the level. Mobile LCP improved sharply, while desktop LCP, mobile INP and CLS all got worse. A single 28-day window would have shown none of that. 5.8 stays Pending: 12 of 25 pages gate content behind a click, and no vetted tool yet tests whether that content is absent from what Google indexes, so the verdict fails toward Pending.

Open cluster 05 →
Cluster 06 · 7 claims

Title links, meta descriptions and snippets

3 Pass · 2 Partial · 2 N/A

Titles are in good shape. 6.5 is the story here: a Gap that turned out to be our own parser bug, then a Pass that was only true of the 25 priority pages, then a Partial once a purpose-built tool found 202 of 428 pages on boilerplate descriptions.

Open cluster 06 →
Cluster 07 · 6 claims

Headings and semantic content structure

2 Pass · 2 Partial · 1 N/A · 1 Pending

Heading order is clean, with one h1 per page. The finding is 7.4: every page nests repeated navigation inside <main>, which is one template decision and one fix. Three tool defects were caught in piloting. One would have produced a false Gap across all 25 pages.

Open cluster 07 →
Cluster 08 · 8 claims

Content quality, helpful content and E-E-A-T

1 Pass · 2 Gap · 1 Partial · 2 N/A · 2 Pending

Crawl and rendered views agree on every verdict, so the findings are content gaps, not delivery problems. There is no authorship signal (8.4) and no citation apparatus (8.5) on any priority page, and 4 pages lack sameAs links (8.7). Judgement calls with no site-side observable are held rather than forced into a verdict.

Open cluster 08 →
Cluster 09 · 8 claims

Keyword relevance and search intent

1 Pass · 1 Gap · 1 Partial · 1 N/A · 4 Pending

Titles pass. Anchor text is the Gap: not one of the 25 pages passes 9.6. Alt text exists everywhere but is often reused across many images (9.7). Keyword repetition is reported without a verdict, because Google publishes no threshold and we won't invent one.

Open cluster 09 →

Want this run on your site?

We test your site against the same claims, record a verdict and the evidence for each one, and tell you what to fix first.

Start a conversation